About Me

My photo
Los Angeles, California, United States
The blog 'Breaking Bread' is for a civil general discussion, like you might have at the dinner table with guests. The posts 'Economics Without the B.S.' are intended for a general audience that wouldn't have to know the difference between a Phillips Curve, a Laffer Curve, or a Cole Hamels Curve. Vic Volpe was formally educated at Penn State and the University of Scranton, with major studies in History, Economics and Finance, and Business; and, is self-educated since by way of books and on-line university courses. His practical education came from sixty years of work experience in the blue-collar trades as well as a white-collar professional career -- a white-collar professional career in production and R&D. In his professional career and as a long-haul trucker, he has traveled throughout the lower forty-eight. From his professional career alone he has visited many manufacturing plants in the United States, Europe and China. He has lived in major metropolitan areas and very small towns in various parts of the United States. He served three years with the U.S. Army as an enlisted man, much of that time in Germany.

Monday, November 16, 2026

What Is America To Me?

 

Economics Without The B.S.**: 


[**  Double entendre intended.]


Secretary of State (and National Security Advisor) Marco Rubio was traveling in Europe visiting allies, and in his stop in Greece delivered this address.

"Under the leadership of the President and Secretary of State, the U.S. Department of State leads America’s foreign policy through diplomacy, advocacy, and assistance by
advancing the interests of the American people, their safety and economic prosperity. On behalf of the American people we promote and demonstrate democratic values and advance a free, peaceful, and prosperous world.
The Secretary of State, appointed by the President with the advice and consent of the Senate, is the President's chief foreign affairs adviser. The Secretary carries out the President's foreign policies through the State Department, which includes the Foreign Service, Civil Service and U.S. Agency for International Development."



"CNN’s Fareed Zakaria in his take, argues that Rubio is wrong about what makes the West exceptional. Also, Fareed talks to former Canadian deputy prime minister Chrystia Freeland on President Trump’s decision to waive sanctions on Russia and and the resulting breakdown between Trump and Zelensky.

In a well-written speech last week delivered against the magnificent backdrop of the Acropolis in Athens, Secretary of State Marco Rubio urged the West to rediscover what makes it exceptional. He described the qualities that define Western civilization as “the fire of passion, strength, courage, pride,” and he celebrated its ambition, nationalism and relentless pursuit of excellence. He warned that the West has become ashamed of the very things that made it great."




[Now my take:]
I understand that our Secretary of State is in Greece and wants to introduce his topic by relating that to the classic traditions of our “Enlightenment”. But to add my “Take” on to Fareed’s, I would make a distinction between the Ancient Greek democracy and Roman Republic with what I would call the “American-style of democratic governance", which is a little different but that small difference is very significant in how our style of governing gives more promise to its sustainability over the ancient traditions. Our Founders were very much aware of the ancient traditions plus the European Enlightenment that preceded the American Revolution. In my opinion, while we have a continuum from that tradition, you have to hold up 1776 as a marker in world history. That was our revolution which laid a governing foundation on the natural rights of all people (not just some people) and gave a justification for governing systems (the consent of the governed). We take that for granted today, but that was revolutionary in the late 18th century. And twelve years later they established a governing system; and during that time Europe, with the French Revolution, was establishing a new governing system. But our system is not an idealistic system, like the French. Our system was based on practicality; how could it be anything else if it permitted slavery, let alone did not recognize the natural rights of half the population – women. [And that is a statement, and not a question] Our system emphasized two principles: individual liberty and a united nation. If you don’t agree with me, read President Washington’s ‘Farewell Address’ when he leaves office in 1796/1797. It is over thirty pages and mentions “union” twelve times and “liberty” fifteen times. And this message was reinforced by President Lincoln during the Civil War with the ‘Gettysburg Address’, less than 300 words but mentioning (1) “our fathers brought forth on this continent a new nation conceived in liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal” (2) And “that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom – and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.” The edifice of American-styled democracy is not to be found in marbled buildings, like the Acropolis, or in marbled temples and statues, though we have those. It is to be found in our “Common Man” mythology, which also is abundant in our popular culture through the ages. It is the people who re-shaped the continental landscape as they expanded westward. And the most obvious place today where you see this is in the Great Plains of Western Nebraska and Western Kansas and Eastern Colorado. Just a little over 150 years ago, not that long ago, well over one million buffalo/bison roamed. This speech by our Secretary of State is important. It was given in Europe which is undergoing challenges to its democratic governance, from within as well as beyond. Marco Rubio has presidential ambitions. Like, Fareed Zakaria said, his speech subordinated our values to our common interests, and raised cultural values and nationalism over universal values and a liberal-democratic ideology which have guided us through our history and especially was the basis for the world leadership position we took on after the conclusion of a world war.

No comments:

Post a Comment